TOEFL Academic Discussion Practice 036

Writing task
Professor
“In our class on animal behavior, we’ve been discussing how humans perceive and interact with different dog breeds. Some people believe that certain breeds, like Pit Bulls or Rottweilers, are naturally aggressive and dangerous. Others argue that a dog’s temperament depends more on its upbringing, environment, and training rather than its breed. Based on your understanding of this issue, do you think certain dog breeds are inherently more aggressive, or is a dog’s behavior primarily shaped by external factors?”
Student A
Angel
“I believe that certain dog breeds, especially those that were historically bred for guarding or fighting, have a natural inclination toward aggression. Their physical strength and instincts make them more dangerous if not trained properly. For example, Pit Bulls were originally bred for bull-baiting, which shows that their aggressive nature runs deep. It’s important to acknowledge that some dogs are simply more predisposed to aggressive behavior due to genetics.”
Student B
Vahid
“In my opinion, breed alone does not determine a dog’s temperament. I’ve known small dogs that were far more aggressive than larger breeds like Rottweilers. The key factor is how the dog is raised, trained, and socialized. Dogs of any breed can become dangerous if they are not cared for properly. Breed-specific legislation, which targets certain breeds as inherently dangerous, misses the point because it’s the owner’s responsibility to manage their dog’s behavior.”
Write a post that contributes to the discussion. Express and support your opinion in your own words. An effective response will contain at least 100 words.